Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Lou Tilsley's avatar

The interesting thing about a great front person is that I can think of many who put on a fantastic show while not playing an instrument but I can never be 100% sure that they don’t at some point pick up a guitar and it’s just escaped my memory. I agree that Alex Turner is a phenomenon whether he is playing or not and I would say the same for Justin Hayward -Young from the Vaccines who might suffer from the over theatricality Newski referred to but does it with extreme style that is just a joy to watch. Zach Lount from King No-One is another great example of this. He often performs best when he puts the guitar down. Ricky Wilson and Rick Witter are both great to watch live and I’d also add Bobby from Bad Nerves and Alex Rice from Sports Team to the list. Of course no list of vocalists would be complete without Michael Stipe. I guess maybe he played guitar sometimes? But I mainly just remember him leaning on a mic stand.

I don’t think there are many bands that I’ve enjoyed listening to their recorded music and then been disappointed with the live performance but Opus Kink are absolutely one that I would pay to see over and over again but would never listen to at home. I don’t think it is that the recording is bad, I just don’t think it conveys the energy of their live performance.

I’ve never seen a fist fight in the context of a live gig but there was a well-publicised episode last year when Kyle Falconer punched his band mate from The View on stage. There’s plenty of footage available on line.

Finally, the most nervous I’ve been about meeting someone was when I happened to be in the pub at the same time as Peter Doherty. Irrationally, and inexplicably, I went and hid in the toilets to avoid the dilemma of whether to speak to him. On reflection, it was probably a good decision.

Expand full comment
Hayley Dunlop's avatar

Apologies if I missed this in the episode, but how did you come to be at a right-leaning (from what I understood) literary event dressed as the Men in Black?

And, in case anyone reading is interested...

Is Sarah McLachlan a good hang? Is Eddie Vedder better?

- 🤷‍♀️

In your life — excepting the family of a potential spouse — who were you most nervous to meet?

- Eddie (Suzy) Izzard at a left-leaning political conference. Undoubtedly the worst conversation I have ever offered up to any human and she quickly 'did a Dave Grohl' 🫠

Who’s the best frontperson that doesn’t play an instrument?

- I'll hand over to Lou T for this one 😘

Seen any good standup comedy specials lately?

- Joe Lycett's More, More, More!

- Mae Martin's SAP.

Which bands’ studio albums are unequivocally, without exception, better than their live shows?

- My Vitriol (mainly since they rarely play live. But, also, their rare live shows make my eyes hurt via overuse of strobe lighting).

Which bands’ live shows possess a magic that none of their albums manage to capture, or even make up for?

- All albums I listen to possess magic. Otherwise I wouldn't listen to them 💅

In the context of live entertainment, have you seen a fist fight?

- I am often breaking up fights at gigs. Most recently at an Ash / The Subways show. As a small woman, this is annoying. But, also as a small woman, my interventions are effective.

Expand full comment
18 more comments...

No posts